i had someone once literally tell me, in exact words, that they'd be totally fine with me critting them for anything. we were castmates.

i critted them once. it was fair crit, imo. no personal attacks and i gave them tips on how to improve.

i never heard the end of the whining and at some point they grudgewanked the shit out of me. (i always fly under the radar and they didn't hide their typing style so i knew it was them.)

being honest without anonymous is a risk.