I don't disagree with you, she really shouldn't have been accepted. But once someone is already in the game, it should take more to kick them out of said game than the word of anons. Because they're already in the game, they're not hiding who they are, and if an anon not already in the game sees that and does not want to play with them (general 'them', I'm talking about cases besides Phase's here too) then they can join another game instead.

Someone playing in Game X does not affect anyone who is not in Game X, so people who are not in Game X should not get a say in what happens in Game X. Only people who ARE in Game X should get a say, and the moment mods start siding with anons over players that are already in their game is the moment players stop giving mods the benefit of the doubt.