Yeah, same. I was really glad someone put in that much time to write such thorough crit, too, because I know I would not have had the patience to go through everything like that. But all of it seemed reasonable, polite, and backed up by examples in his playing vs. canon, so the fact that he is ignoring it and won't even reply to it reflects poorly on him.

TBQH, this whole situation makes me really miss Anna's Catman.